Save the Best for Last

Get a major sugar rush with one of our delicious desserts

Complete your meal with a sugary dessert from Big Jay's Pizzeria. We have a menu of cannolis and cakes galore. You can even order a flaky lobster tail pastry that's packed with a creamy filling.

Finish your meal on a sweet note. Order dessert from our restaurant today. We offer dine-in, delivery and pickup for customers in the Marcy, NY area.

Celebrate your special occasion with a sweet treat

Are you preparing for an upcoming birthday or anniversary party? Purchase your cake from us! We have fresh cheesecake, Oreo and carrot cake available for pickup. All desserts are made fresh and guaranteed to leave a lasting impression.
Spend your cheat day with us. Visit our restaurant today to try one of our delicious dessert options. We won't judge you if you choose to try them all.

  • Deep Fried Oreos
  • Cheesecake
  • Carrot Cake
  • Fried Dough Chunks
  • Pusties
  • Lobster Tails
  • Oreo Cake
  • Canoli's